Dining in Flagstaff & Northern Arizona
Flagstaff Pizza

August 26, 2026

NiMarco's Pizza: A Local Slice Near Downtown Flagstaff

A Flagstaff pizzeria mainstay serving hand-built pies in a casual, family-friendly room, with a downtown location that has made it a go-to for locals.

By Mike Konefal | 4 min read
A wood-fired pizza with charred crust, melted mozzarella, and fresh basil on a dark wooden board

NiMarco's Pizza has served Flagstaff for a long stretch, and its downtown outpost keeps the tradition alive for a new generation. It is the kind of neighborhood pizzeria locals rely on: no fuss, good pie, and a room that welcomes families and walk-ins alike.

What to Know

  • A long-running Flagstaff pizzeria with a downtown location
  • Hand-made pizza in a casual, family-friendly room
  • A reliable local favorite for pickup, delivery, or a sit-down meal

The menu stays classic, from build-your-own pies to familiar Italian-American favorites, and the dining room has a comfortable, unpretentious feel. On busy weekends, the pick-up counter hums.

For a quick dinner before a show or an easy family meal, NiMarco's does exactly what a local pizza place should: it shows up, consistently, at a fair price.

Locals have their favorite orders; newcomers should not overthink it. A classic pizza and a casual table is the whole point.

Visit the Restaurant's Website

Hours, menus, and reservations change frequently. Check the restaurant's own website for current details.

Mike Konefal, real estate agent and local guide for Flagstaff and Northern Arizona

Mike Konefal

Broker Associate · Coldwell Banker Northland Realty

A Northern Arizona local for more than 26 years, Mike writes this dining guide to help visitors and future residents find the places locals genuinely love.

Ask Mike a Question

Get the weekly Flagstaff newsletter